logo
Login Subscribe
Google Play App Store
  • News
    • Obituaries
    • Lifestyle
    • Opinion
  • Sports
  • E-edition
  • Calendar
  • Archives
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Advertisers
    • Form Submission
    • About Us
    • News
      • Obituaries
      • Lifestyle
      • Opinion
    • Sports
    • E-edition
    • Calendar
    • Archives
    • Contact
      • Contact Us
      • Advertisers
      • Form Submission
      • About Us
DOGE underscores gradual power shift between legislative, executive branches
commentary
March 6, 2025
DOGE underscores gradual power shift between legislative, executive branches

This may be the most difficult column I have ever written. When it comes to the Department of Government Efficiency, I really have no idea what’s going on. How is that for an opener?

What makes me feel better is I don’t think anyone else really has an idea of what is completely going on, especially with what is and what is not legal. There are a few aspects I can talk about confidently, but like everyone else, I still have more questions than answers. Hopefully history can clarify a few aspects.

In my Colonial America class, I give an example of a 16-yearold who gets a car from his parents for his birthday. He’s a good kid and now that he has transportation, his parents extend his curfew to midnight. Eventually, the kid realizes his parents are asleep when he gets in and aren’t paying attention to when he gets home. After several months, the kid starts coming in at 1 or 2 a.m. without any parental recourse. After about a year, one night he walks in, flips on the light and sees his parents waiting on the couch. They ground him for his tardiness. The kid’s response is that it’s not fair; his parents had to know he was coming in late and yet, had not punished before now.

Who is right? The kid or the parents? In class, we normally conclude that there is fault on both sides. I explain that this is how our American Revolution began. For more than 100 years, the British government had left the colonies alone without enforcing rules. Smuggling and other acts became a way of life. Then one day, we walked in to find our parents (the king) upset because we broke the rules. Our moment getting caught was when, during the French and Indian War, the Crown sent troops and bureaucrats over who discovered we were not behaving properly. Our “That’s not fair” movement sparked the revolution.

This also applies to our political situation today. For more than 100 years, Congress has willingly allowed presidents to slowly strip away its power as it is easier to allow the president to work harder and take either all the credit or the blame. Congress never had to do anything controversial, increasing their reelection chances. Common issues today would never have been turned over to the president in the 1800s. Our living room light came on when Trump and Musk began eliminating programs. Now, suddenly, Congress — at least the Democrats — care and are claiming it’s not fair. In essence, Trump is doing what other presidents have done while no one stopped them. He’s just taken the next step with DOGE. The problem is it may be too late to stop the trend.

Many question DOGE’s legality. Can the president create a new government agency? The answer: probably yes. But that’s because DOGE was not created by Trump alone. In 2014, after the Obamacare rollout, Obama created the United States Digital Service as a way of making all online services more efficient and staffed it with young Silicon Valley employees. Trump has taken that organization and renamed and rebranded it as DOGE. It’s not a new agency, just a new name. While this seems above water, the constitutional issue revolves around defunding organizations Congress had previously approved, like USAID (United States Agency for International Development). While many are excited about the cuts, Constitutionally, Congress controls the checkbook. Historically speaking, there have been instances where presidents have not used the money as it was intended. This is known as Impoundment, and was first used by Thomas Jefferson.

In 1803, Congress approved funds to purchase gunboats on the Mississippi River to possibly defend the nation’s right to use New Orleans. That same year, Jefferson’s Louisiana Purchase included New Orleans, so he did not make the purchases as there was no longer a need. After that, presidents regularly used impoundments when they felt the government did not need to spend as much as Congress had approved on any project. Impoundments were common practice until Nixon’s presidency.

Nixon used impoundment so frequently that Congress felt that his withholding of approved program funds was the same as terminating programs. In 1972, when he vetoed the Federal Water Pollution Control Act amendment, Congress overrode his veto and passed the bill. Instead of allocating funds to the states under the program, Nixon impounded them. The City of New York sued Russell E. Train, an Environmental Protection Agency administrator, for the funds based on the grounds that the president had overstepped his authority. In 1975’s Train v. City of New York, the Supreme Court agreed.

While the Court considered the case, Congress passed the Impoundment Control Act of 1974 which allowed the president to rescind funds only if both branches of Congress agreed. Clinton tried to regain some control with the Line-Item Veto Act of 1996, which allowed the president to cut congressional spending, but the Court found the law unconstitutional. Legally, it seems as if DOGE should have congressional permission to cut funding to government agencies. Yet, the cuts are still happening.

As I see it, even with laws limiting the executive branch’s power, the legislative branch will have to work together to enforce them. Recent history shows us that Democrats and Republicans usually don’t play well together and only seem concerned with presidential power when the other party’s president is in office. It also took more than a century for Congress to have its power stripped away, so it may take just as long to reclaim it.

Trump’s success is that elected officials have always claimed they want to fix wasteful spending, but no one has ever done anything. Watching the attacks on Trump, it is clear why. Everyone wants government spending controlled until it impacts their interests or their supporters’ interests. Too many have benefited for too long on government money. My issue is, even if we support the DOGE cuts, and there are many that I do, this is setting precedent that will also apply to future presidents with whom we may not agree.

While the courts will probably decide what is and is not legal with the DOGE cuts, no one can claim that Trump is afraid to do what he promised to do. Cutting government waste was what made him popular.

James Finck is a professor of American history at the University of Science and Arts of Oklahoma. He can be reached at HistoricallySpeak-ing1776@ gmail.com.

Checotah lit up the sky this 4th of July
A: Main, News...
Checotah lit up the sky this 4th of July
By LADONNA RHODES STAFF WRITER 
July 10, 2025
The City of Checotah showed off its bold stripes, bright stars and brave hearts this Fourth of July after working countless hours so residents could celebrate their freedom with lots of family fun and...
this is a test
A: Main, News...
Sexual Assault Awareness Honor Walk
July 10, 2025
Friday, July 11 at 12 p.m. Posey Park, Eufaula Show your support for survivors Take a stand against violence! Muscogee (Creek) Nation Center for Victim Services
this is a test
A: Main, News...
Annual Memorial Service planned at Honey Springs Battlefield
July 10, 2025
CHECOTAH — Honey Springs Battlefield will hold its annual memorial service on Saturday, July 19, at 10:30 a.m. to honor the 162nd anniversary of the Battle of Honey Springs near Checotah. The service ...
this is a test
Farewell to Checotah’s friend, Jerri Reaves
A: Main, News...
Farewell to Checotah’s friend, Jerri Reaves
By LADONNA RHODES STAFF WRITER 
July 10, 2025
Last Thursday family and friends said goodbye to former city councilwoman Jerri Reaves who had passed away on June 26 at the age of 82. Jerri graduated from Checotah High School in 1962. In 1980, she ...
this is a test
News
Trump administration freezes over $70 million state’s education funds
By NURIA MARTINEZ-KEEL OKLAHOMA VOICE 
July 10, 2025
States won’t receive funds from six federal programs, including after-school care and English learner support, until further notice. OKLAHOMA CITY — The Trump administration is indefinitely withholdin...
this is a test
News
Jeff Starling launches campaign for attorney general
July 10, 2025
TULSA ––Jeff Starling, Oklahoma’s Secretary of Energy and Environment, has officially announced his candidacy for Attorney General of Oklahoma. Starling is a conservative, attorney, businessman, and d...
this is a test
United for Oklahoma
ePaper
coogle_play
app_store
Editor Picks
Plumb Theatre News
News
Plumb Theatre News
By MATTIE AND PAUL MALOY PLUMB THEATRE 
July 10, 2025
Never too early to start singing and the HALLELUJAH HONEYS are representative of that. Kate Andrews will be singing and playing with two other Honeys, Aubree,13, and Charlee, 10. They are some cuties ...
this is a test
Freedom Fest
News
Freedom Fest
July 10, 2025
Checotah residents celebrated their freedom with lots of family fun and fireworks on July 4th weekend at Freedom Fest.
this is a test
Police training
News
Police training
July 10, 2025
Recently local law enforcement trained for two days on different scenarios that might arise during traffic stops, hostage situations, domestic disturbances, and more.
this is a test
News
Two from area on UCO Honor Rolls
July 10, 2025
EDMOND - Two from this area have made he University of Central Oklahoma recently announced the students named to the university’s honor rolls; a distinction given to those who achieve the highest acad...
this is a test
Warriors of God, ready yourselves
commentary
Warriors of God, ready yourselves
July 10, 2025
Of my 56 years of being in this world, 50 of those years I have been filled with the Holy Spirit with the evidence of speaking in tongues. I was only six years old when I attended my first Tiger Mount...
this is a test
Facebook
Twitter
Tweets
Twitter
Tweets

MCINTOSH COUNTY DEMOCRAT
300-A S. Broadway
Checotah, OK
74426

(918) 473-2313

This site complies with ADA requirements

© 2023 Mcintosh Democrat

  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Accessibility Policy